Blog: Daisy News

News, data, & insights about workers' comp billing

Header illustration blog

Maximus Gets It Wrong in 99358 IBR Decision

August 31, 2017 by Catherine Montgomery

Maximus federal drops IBR ballMaximus Federal Services, the arbiter of Independent Bill Review (IBR) for the California Division of Workers’ Compensation (DWC), has denied payment to a provider due to a an error on Maximus’ own part. The mistake, based on an outdated status code designation for CPT codes 99358 and 99359, is one DaisyBill anticipated. With Maximus behind the curve on changes to the Official Medical Fee Schedule (OMFS) effective this year, other providers may be in danger of the similar mistreatment.

99358 and 99359 are CPT codes for billing prolonged services without direct face-to-face contract. The codes are typically (but not exclusively) used to bill for time spent reviewing records (for any time spent exceeding 30 minutes). For most of its history, 99358 was billable; it was a paid service under the DWC schedule’s Table A for over nine years. That changed when SB 863 upended the work comp system, replacing the DWC Table A with the Medicare-aligned RBRVU-based physician fee schedule.

99358 history 

Table A under DWC schedule

The RBRVU-based Physician Fee Schedule took effect in January 2014. At that point, the OMFS designated 99358 as a status code “B,” which meant that 99358 was no longer reimbursable. For over three years, 99358 was not payable, and claims administrators acted accordingly.

All that changed on March 1, when the acting Administrative Director of the DWC adopted Medicare’s RVUs for 2017. Under the new fee schedule, RVU17A designated 99358 status code “A,” a payable service for all dates of service on or after March 1, 2017.

Status Code A for 99358

Which brings us to the current Maximus debacle: on March 10 of this year, a claims administrator approved a doctor’s request for authorization (RFA) “to issue a narrative report to include medical records review with appropriate payment per OMFS.” The doctor submitted an original bill for that record review using CPT codes 99358 and 99359 to document the time spent on the authorized services. The claims administrator, however, denied the bill. Let me repeat, the claims administrator authorized the services, yet the claims administrator refused to pay the bill.

The doctor, not a client of DaisyBill, appealed the denial with a request for Second Review, which was also denied. Ultimately, the doctor filed a request for Independent Review to appeal the incorrect Second Review denial. Maximus upheld the denial based on the following:

“CPT Code 99358 and CPT Code 99359 are are both listed as status code “B” in column D of the Medicare Physician Fee Schedule Relative Value File. Status code “B” means: ‘Bundled Code, payment for covered services are always bundled into payment for other services not specified.’”

The bottom line: Maximus is wrong.

Since the adoption of RVU17 by the DWC, Maximus’ information is outdated. As anyone who deals with workers’ comp billing knows, fee schedules change often. Staying on top of those changes is crucial to maintaining accuracy in reimbursement. In this case, the Maximus IBR decision incorrectly applied an outdated reimbursement standard.

Given the effort providers expend at every stage, this decision by Maximus amounts to a gross injustice.

No provider should have to accept improper reimbursement because the firm in charge of IBR missed the updated fee schedule memo. Consider the doctor’s staggering administrative costs, just to provide an authorized service:

  1. Submitting a proper RFA for authorization,
  2. Submitting a complete and compliant original bill
  3. Requesting second bill review (SBR) to appeal an incorrect denial
  4. Resubmitting all of the documentation for Independent Bill Review
  5. Paying $195 IBR filing fee

All of these steps cost time and administrative resources. This doctor deserves praise for tenaciously demanding the correct payment for their services. California workers comp should be ashamed of the mistreatment of doctors like this one— doctors who continue to help injured workers despite enormous administrative impediments and inept decisions like this one by Maximus.


Unlike Maximus, DaisyBill stays ahead of the curve on changes to California's Official Medical Fee Schedule (OMFS). We offer webinars on this year’s most important changes to work comp, and specifically on CPT Codes 99358 and 99539.

Our OMFS calculator takes the latest information on fee schedules into account, while our Essential Tools Software makes RFA’s, billing, and requests for appeals fast, compliant, and effective. Don’t allow your office to be cheated out of correct reimbursements: schedule a free demonstration today.

REQUEST DEMO

Search results for:

About Us Logo small inverted

DaisyBill is a trusted authority on workers’ comp billing. Thousands of work comp professionals attend our webinars and state agencies and professional organizations turn to us for our expertise. We created this blog to help everyone involved in workers’ compensation; sharing news, tips, and data of interest to the community.

Drop us a line with any news you would like us to share or any issue that concerns you.

Chat bubble