2021 Med-Legal Fee Schedule Changes -- Join us for a free webinar on April 15 at 1pm PDT
Broadspire Knows No Law But Its Own

Broadspire Knows No Law But Its Own

Broadspire continues to break the rules, seemingly confident that California regulators will not hold the claims administrator to account.

For months, we reported on Broadspire’s noncompliance regarding Second Review appeals. DaisyBill representatives contacted Broadspire and its clearinghouse to explain California requirements. As shown below, we thoroughly documented Broadspire’s refusal to act compliantly, and filed audit complaints with the Division of Workers’ Compensation (DWC).

But in the absence of decisive enforcement action, Broadspire continues to act as though they are exempt from DWC rules.

Broadspire’s Lawlessness Affects Employers

To dispute an incorrect reimbursement or payment denial, California regulations require a provider to submit a Second Review appeal in the same manner as the provider initially submitted the original bill; i.e. electronically or non-electronically.

Regulations also require payers to accept both original bills and Second Review appeals electronically.

Yet Broadspire refuses to accept electronic Second Review appeals despite the rules — and despite accepting electronic original bills. By their actions, Broadspire makes it more difficult for providers to treat the employees of every employer for whom Broadspire administers claims.

For each of the companies listed below, providers treated at least one employee only to have Broadspire deny or reduce reimbursement paid to the provider. In each case, Broadspire refused to accept the provider’s compliant electronic Second Review appeal disputing the incorrect payment.

99 Cents Only Store


Aldersly Care Center

Anning Johnson Co.

Avantor/VWR International

Baxter HealthCare Corp

Bridge Property Management

California Sports Service

Capin Crouse

Casa de las Campanas



Chipotle Mexican Grill


DS Services of America

Eco Lab

Employ Bridge/ Select Staffing

Extended Stay America

Finish Master Inc

Forever 21

Freeman Management dba McDonalds

Gulf Stream

Henley Restaurants

Herc Rentals


Keolis Transit America


Mission Linen Supply


MV Transportation


Olympus America

Orange Bakery, Inc.

Owens And Minor, Inc

Pentair Water Pool & Spa/Chino

Real Time Staffing Services

Red Robin International

Saia Motor Freight Lines, Inc.

Salon Centric

Select Staffing

Sparkletts Water


The Karsten Company

The Select Family Staffing Company


TVI Inc.

University of Southern California

West Hills Hospital

Wonderful Orchards

To be absolutely clear, Broadspire’s business practice is unambiguously noncompliant with California Second Review regulations. In total, Broadspire attempted to skirt processing Second Review appeals representing over $50,000 in disputed reimbursements, to the detriment of the entire workers’ comp system.

Is Broadspire the New DWC?

DaisyBill representatives have repeatedly contacted Broadspire’s clearinghouse, Availity, about the failure to process the Second Reviews submitted electronically by providers.

Availity explained to DaisyBill that Broadspire has its own, unilateral “rules” for Second Review appeals. According to Availity, until further notice, providers may only submit Second Review appeals via paper mail. Further, per Broadspire “rules” providers must also include the original Explanation of Review (EOR), a Broadspire-specific requirement that is absent from any state regulation.

Which begs the question: When was Broadspire appointed Administrative Director of the DWC?

California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 9792.5.5(c)(2) requires providers to submit Second Review appeals electronically. Section 9792.5.5(g) requires claims administrators to respond to Second Review appeals within 14 calendar days. These are straightforward California regulations to which most claims administrators adhere.

Yet, somehow, Broadspire considers these regulations optional.

Audit Complaints Filed

As advocates for fair billing and payment practices in workers’ comp, we submitted multiple audit complaints against Broadspire for their abject refusal to honor compliant Second Review appeals. Below is the latest example. We intend to continue demanding compliance from this insurer.

The only question is, how long will the DWC stand for Broadspire’s noncompliance?

When payers misbehave, DaisyBill has your back. Our easy, instant appeal submission and tracking tools help your office stay on top of accounts receivable. Reach out to learn how.


Subscribe to DaisyNews

Recent Posts

Popular Topics

California (486) claims administrators Billing Education News Updates Fee Schedule OMFS Second Review e-Billing California DWC RFA medical-legal
New York (5) CMS 1500 Billing Education Electronic Billing e-Billing