A new study from the National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI) examines how long it takes workers to receive their first medical treatment after an injury and the potential impact of delays on overall treatment duration.
Broadly, across all claims and states included in the study, the NCCI found that the time to first treatment increased by two days from 2016 to 2023, while treatment duration remained essentially unchanged.
However, a different picture emerged when the NCCI isolated injuries requiring Physical Therapy (PT) and major surgery. The study found direct correlations between longer waits for workers to receive their first PT visit or surgery and longer overall care duration. Jurisdictions where time to first PT or surgery grew the most tended to see the largest increases in treatment duration.
Translation: Where wait times to start PT or get surgery grew longer, injured workers stayed in treatment longer.
The study examined lost-time claims (excluding medical-only claims) in 36 states and the District of Columbia, all of which rely on the NCCI to help determine loss costs and workers’ comp premium rates.
Notably, the NCCI study does not include California, the largest workers’ comp market in the United States. To study its comp system, California relies almost exclusively on a separate rating bureau managed by insurers (excluding data from self-insured employers, which cover roughly one in eight California workers). Moreover, California has no reliable systemwide data on treatment utilization.
As the NCCI’s chart below shows, from 2016 to 2023, wait times for the first medical services following an injury increased, rising from 13 to 15 days on average.
Additionally, the percentage of lost-time claims treated on the date of injury fell from 48% to 43% over that period. However, there seemed to be no significant impact on overall treatment duration, which rose only a fraction of a day on average, from 217.8 days in 2016 to 218 days flat in 2023.
As the NCCI put it in their own summary (emphasis ours):
But the numbers told a different story when the NCCI zoomed in on PT and surgery.
As the chart above shows, for PT, the time to first treatment climbed more significantly, from 47 to 55 days on average, an 8-day increase. Average wait times for major surgery went up 10 days, from 113 to 123 days.
The NCCI chart below shows that in many states, a longer time to the first PT visit was associated with a longer treatment duration. This was not the case in every state included in the study, but the pattern held broadly. According to the NCCI, every additional day of waiting for the first PT visit was associated with about two more days in treatment (emphasis ours):
The pattern was even stronger for injuries requiring major surgery. In most states, longer waits for surgery went hand in hand with longer treatment, and shorter waits with shorter treatment.
At least for injuries requiring PT or surgery, eliminating delays in care may be critical to minimizing the amount of treatment the worker requires and, therefore, decreasing claim duration, disability costs, medical costs, and other expenses.
California, where claims take twice as long to resolve as the national median, urgently needs a thorough analysis of treatment delays and their potential impact on overall treatment and claim durations.
Sadly, it’s unlikely to get one anytime soon.
California relies almost exclusively on the Workers’ Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau (WCIRB) for research on claim statistics, despite concerns about its data sources and methodologies, including credible accusations that it “skews” the numbers to its members’ benefit.
A decade ago, the state legislature mandated that the California Division of Workers’ Compensation (CA DWC) establish a mandatory electronic reporting system for all utilization review documents. Under a separate law, the agency was also required to make all payers report all claim data to the centralized Workers’ Compensation Information System (WCIS). Under its previous leadership, the agency did neither.
Because the CA DWC ignored state law, California cannot meaningfully study the critical issue of treatment during the early days of an injury.
Instead, California paid RAND $300,000 for a study of UR in the first 30 days of a claim, which was almost entirely based on voluntarily supplied data from two anonymous payers. RAND noted that its ability to conduct the study was “constrained by the absence of systemwide data” and produced only one substantive policy recommendation: “Invest in Utilization Review Data Infrastructure.”
The notion that accelerating access to care may improve outcomes and reduce claim costs is supported by available data, anecdotal evidence, and common sense. Most states now have at least one study to support it. California has…work to do.
DaisyBill provides content as an insightful service to its readers and clients. It does not offer legal advice and cannot guarantee the accuracy or suitability of its content for a particular purpose.
By the grace of God, NCCI has figured it out, longer wait times for surgery+PT equals longer treatment/care. What a remarkable achievement in "the system".