CA Can (and Should) Do Better Than the WCIRB

CA Can (and Should) Do Better Than the WCIRB

California workers’ comp can only break out of its current dysfunction with a clear, objective view of its systemic problems, based on unbiased analyses of data around treatment utilization and claim costs.

The first logical step in achieving that visibility is to end the state’s reliance on the Workers’ Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau (WCIRB).

The WCIRB is not the only impediment to a better workers’ comp system. It is, however, the primary impediment to a more thorough, dispassionate, and actionable grasp of how the system works, where it fails, and what stakeholders must do to fix it.

For years, daisyNews has reported on problems with the WCIRB’s data and methods, most significantly the opacity of both; no independent authority can scrutinize the raw figures underlying WCIRB reports, which are typically based solely on unverified data supplied by its insurer members.

Moreover, there is obvious financial self-interest for WCIRB insurers, who dominate its Governing and Actuarial Committees, in the narratives implied by their reports. Some experts have even gone so far as to openly accuse the WCIRB of “skewing” its data to benefit insurers.

Ironically enough, California legislators mandated an alternative to the WCIRB’s near-total control of the narratives around workers’ comp. Decade-old laws require the California Division of Workers’ Compensation (CA DWC) to:

Under its previous leadership, the CA DWC has failed to accomplish either mandate, which would provide stakeholders with comprehensive data to produce meaningful, actionable studies.

California employers pay some of the highest premiums in the nation to fund one of the least effective, least efficient comp systems. Reform cannot happen without comprehensive (or at least representative) data, analyzed transparently and objectively.

The Limits on WCIRB Data

More than any other single organization, the WCIRB informs the understanding (and the decisions) of regulators, lawmakers, and industry analysts.

  • By law, it must produce an annual report on insurer losses and expenses to the State Legislature.
  • Its data and reporting form much of the basis for the annual reports of the Commission on Health and Safety and Workers’ Compensation (CHSWC).
  • Each year it files official recommendations for the state’s pure premium advisory rate with California’s Insurance Commissioner.

Any organization with that level of influence should base its reporting on the largest, most representative data sets possible. But the WCIRB’s data are constrained in several important ways.

First, the data come only from insurers, completely excluding self-insured employers, which cover roughly one in eight California workers.

Plus, depending on the report, only a limited swath of its insurer data may be included. For example, a recent WCIRB presentation to CHSWC on Cumulative Trauma (CT) claims spanning several years was based on surveys of just 400 claims. Its most recent mandatory report on loss costs discloses that “some” of its information “may have been estimated” on data “representing less than 100 percent of the insured market,” with no further information as to how much less.

Finally, no independent party can audit the underlying data of WCIRB reports, which is not accessible to the public.

A Question of Interest

California is not the only state to rely on a rating bureau composed of or controlled by insurers for comp analysis. Moreover, most states rely on the National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI), which is also insurer-controlled.

That acknowledged, loss costs and premium rates are dropping in almost every state outside of California, including NCCI states and other states with separate rating bureaus.

California’s exclusion from the national trend, coupled with the opacity of WCIRB data and reporting, makes it reasonable to point out that WCIRB members benefit when its reporting implies problematic medical spending and consistently seeks (however unconvincingly) to justify higher premiums.

Going even further, analysts at Workers’ Comp Executive declared in 2024 that the WCIRB “skews” the data behind its annual reports to the State Legislature by excluding income sources for insurers and “intermingling” private insurer data with those of the state’s non-profit insurer of last resort.

As daisyNews has consistently pointed out, WCIRB reporting focuses almost exclusively on trends such as medical cost growth and CT claims, repeatedly stoking narratives about providers driving costs. Meanwhile:

  • The WCIRB itself acknowledges that California claims cost twice the national median in legal and administrative expenses like bill review, network contracting, and UR to deliver care and benefits.
  • Delays in approving care may be contributing to higher attorney involvement and, in turn, greater claim costs.
  • WCIRB reporting often includes Medical-Legal services (which resolve disputes over payer liability and involve zero treatment) among “medical” costs.

In other words, insurers are almost certainly making choices that are driving claim costs. Yet the WCIRB’s focus remains squarely on doctors as the problem (e.g., a recent change to WCIRB methodology reframed medical cost trends to downplay overall price growth and to show a surge in provider utilization of more expensive services).

The Answer: Follow the Law and Build State Databases

This is not to say that there’s no role for independent rating bureaus, including the WCIRB, in achieving visibility into workers’ comp. However, the current level of reliance on the WCIRB hinders stakeholders’ understanding of how to repair this crumbling system.

The California Legislature already mandated the most obvious solution: publicly controlled, comprehensive statewide databases on every comp claim in the state, including required reporting of every document related to treatment utilization.

Since 2017, state law has mandated that the CA DWC require all payers to report data on all claims to the WCIS (which, somewhat ironically, was developed with the assistance of the WCIRB). Instead, the CA DWC has for years eschewed enforcement of data reporting requirements in favor of “encouraging voluntary compliance.”

Additionally, the Legislature has passed laws mandating that the CA DWC:

The agency never established the reporting system, never published the data it never gathered, and only commissioned the UR study in 2025, from RAND. That study produced no substantive information, instead noting the absence of UR data from which to draw conclusions and recommending that California “invest in Utilization Review Data Infrastructure.”

With a properly functioning WCIS and UR reporting system in place, California would have real options for studying the comp system, with or without the involvement of the WCIRB, the NCCI, RAND, or any other entity. As it stands, California is basically taking the WCIRB’s conclusions on little more than faith.

For a state with the fourth-highest premiums in the nation, that spends exorbitantly on administrative services that can impede care, and which takes twice as long as the median state to resolve claims, faith is an unacceptable substitute for research.


Get unprecedented visibility into revenue management for workers’ comp treatment with daisyBill. Click to see how:

BILL BETTER: DAISYBILL

0 Reader Comments
There are no comments for this article. Be the first to comment!

DaisyBill provides content as an insightful service to its readers and clients. It does not offer legal advice and cannot guarantee the accuracy or suitability of its content for a particular purpose.